In the wake of the Virginia Tech shootings, there was no shortage of opinions about what was the cause of this tragedy: too much gun control, not enough gun control, video games, a failed psychiatric system, an unresponsive school administration, etc., etc. ad nauseum. But the one opinion that stood out in my mind was posted by James Randi in a satirical “prayer” asking a loving God why He didn’t prevent the horrendous, senseless slaughter at Virginia Tech:
http://www.randi.org/jr/2007-04/042007todd.html#i9
First of all, I can sympathize with anyone who is angry towards God, especially in light of the events at Virginia Tech. Looking back, I was none too pleased with God when my father and mother died in their sixties. But at least in the natural order of things, parents are supposed to die before their children. I can’t imagine the anguish of a parent losing a child at any age. But I suspect that when that child is college age, with so much potential and hope for the future, and under the circumstances at Virginia Tech, it can’t get much worse than that.
As far as why God allows things like the Virginia Tech shootings to happen, for better or worse, He created us with free will. He could have created us as mindless automatons without the means to do anything but his bidding, but then He couldn’t have a dynamic love relationship with us that He has always longed for.
Whether you view Adam and Eve as historical figures or merely allegorical characters, the truth is the same: even if there were only one rule to follow, humans would use their free will to disobey God. When Adam and Eve decided they knew better than God, that perfect relationship was broken. Since that decision, God has allowed us to go our own way, and the Earth has never been the same since.
In order for God to totally take back control of His creation from us, two things would have to take place: all of mankind would have to either have to 1) give up its collective free will; or 2) use that free will to be totally obedient to God. How many people would be willing to do that? Would you?
Randi asks why God created tobacco, cancer, spina bifida, and Crohn’s Disease. I believe that all of these things are a result of the Fall of Man. I know that sounds terribly theological and cold, so let me give you some real life observations:
I’ve seen my own father, stricken with lung cancer after a lifetime of smoking tobacco, face his own death with humor and dignity.
I’ve attended a Christian music concert given by a young man with spina bifida and laughed with his beautiful wife when he joked that they almost didn’t get married because he started getting “cold tires.”
I’ve heard Joni Earickson Tada, a quadriplegic since a diving accident at the age of 17, speak eloquently about how her affliction has actually been a blessing.
I’ve listened to the music of a young Hispanic man, born with no arms, who played guitar beautifully with his feet, and I’ve seen video of Pope John Paul II embracing him after he played for the pontiff.
(Sorry, I’ve never known anyone with Crohn’s Disease.)
So what do all these people have in common? One thing: they all rose above their circumstances and found joy through belief in a God who loved them enough to pay for His broken relationship with them by sacrificing His own Son in an act that was every bit as anguishing as what the parents of the victims at Virginia Tech went through.
About the shootings at Virginia Tech, Randi asks why God did this to us. In doing so, he joins a long line of people, going all the way back to the Garden of Eden, who have tried to use God as a scapegoat. When God asked Adam “Have you eaten from the tree that I commanded you not to eat from?”, Adam replied, “The woman you put here with me — she gave me some fruit from the tree, and I ate it.” [Emphasis added.]
So James Randi wants to place the blame on God for not preventing the Virginia Tech shootings – a God in whom, by his own admission, he doesn’t believe. God gave Randi (or anyone else) the free will to believe that if he so desires.
I just have one question: How’s that working for you?
